Amoeboy's Reviews

[:the Composer:]

good flash

Good music, well played piano, interesting and progressive,kinda poignant,personal, perhaps, but at the same time a little contrite.
I liked that acoustic song at the end too, heard that a long time ago, seems a little patronising to use it in the way you did though

[Lemmings: Deus Ex Machina]

ermm

yeah, It's ok, not really an original flash. Same old shit, different subject. U have obvious skills, it's just a shame u dont use them to make something with some originality.
So the lemmings die in cruel and obvious ways, so what! U should use your talent to construct some new ideas.

[Schiavo's Secret]

ermmm

i don't find it distasteful, but neither do i find it funny or original. it's a really old style gag using a current topic to get it some plaudits, when it really just sux. Hey everyone, here's the Bandwagon, jump on board.

[Grey Story]

hmm...

So, the music is nice, bit repetetive... graphics are okay, simple but effective.

The gameplay itself is far too slow and tedious & the 'reward' for spending time collecting items and giving them to the female character does not justify the means.

Overall I like the concept, but feel it needs a proper injection of pace to actually make this worthwhile playing. As it is it's just far too drawn out and lacklustre.

AB

[the Happiest in the World]

quite good

the piano is quite emotional, you know it's gearing up for a sad sounding song. Your singing voice is not very strong, good pitch, good range, kinda choirboy esque, but it doesn't have a lot of personality, in my opinion. The song's very dramatic, a little cliched, like a musical, not my thing really, but I had to comment because of the good sound quality and because of your film the composer.
The tin whistle sound is nice, but it's all very wishy-washy for my tastes.
I'm sure there's a market for this kind of music, titanic soundtrack or something like that, but I find the more I listen to the more I want to punch you in the face:) And i'm not an agressive person at all. The whisper at the end is just awful in my opinion, so cheesy I could put it on toast and tuck in right now.

Jazza responds:

sure think what u will, but i didnt record it to impress anyone. i recorded it because it's the first time i've felt the reality of a broken heart in this way. Call it cheese, but fact is love is the most powerful thing in the world, therefore anything expressed about it can easily be seen as overdone.

thanks though, you had some good points.

[Moonlight Sonata (full)]

rubbish

something you whipted up in 40 minutes eh.
It's really bad, Beethoven would be rolling in his grave if he could here this midi awful piece of poop.

studio-nightbird responds:

He would be...but its not his version of the song. I changed it to make it more different so then people wont go...eh herd it before.
but yea 40 minutes. since i only have FL studios trial

[Super Freak(28 second loop)]

ok

it has nice feel to it, kinda heavy, kinda good riff, but generally the production sucks and the drums are way too high in the mix compared to the guitars, needs a lot of work and shouldn't be #1 as it's just a work in progress and also a short loop.

Bad-Man-Incorporated responds:

Wow, it's almost as though it hurt your feelings. There is no "production" on this track at all. So your review is close on all fronts, except the whining part. Thanks for the constructive review, though. You should learn to be a little less of a dick though, when leaving reviews. It might piss some people off that give a shit.
Thanks again, man.\m/